Public Backlash and Official Response

The proposal was met with immediate and widespread criticism online, with many Japanese citizens labeling the plan as unrealistic and out of touch with modern life. Social media users argued that smartphones are integral to daily activities, from communication to accessing news.

Critics also raised concerns about government overreach, stating that screen time rules should be determined by individuals and families, not municipal authorities. In response, Toyoake's mayor clarified that the ordinance is not compulsory and recognizes the indispensable role of smartphones in society.

A Familiar Debate in Japan

This is not the first time such a measure has been introduced in Japan. In 2020, Kagawa Prefecture enacted a similar non-binding ordinance limiting children’s gaming to one hour on weekdays. That rule also faced criticism but brought national attention to the issue of youth digital consumption.

A recent survey from Japan’s Children and Families Agency highlights the challenge: Japanese youth spend an average of just over five hours online each weekday, more than double the proposed limit.