Gen Z’s Dating Rules and ‘Ick’ Lists Lead to Disappointment

Viral social media trends are reshaping modern romance, as many Gen Z and Millennial daters use detailed “ick lists” to accept or reject partners, often based on trivial traits.

The Rise of Checklist Dating

Young singles are increasingly navigating the dating world with a new tool: the “ick list.”

This phenomenon, driven by viral social media trends, involves creating detailed checklists of behaviors and traits that can cause immediate romantic rejection. From fashion choices to conversational habits, potential partners are being evaluated against criteria shaped by online culture.

What is an ‘Ick’?

The term “ick,” popularized on platforms like TikTok, describes a trait or action that instantly turns a person off. According to reporting from The Guardian, it’s a gut reaction of disgust that can abruptly end a budding romance.

These icks can be significant, but are often trivial. Lea Veloso shared her list with The Sophian, which included everything from “being an unsuccessful DJ” to “saving oneself for marriage.”

Social Media’s Influence

Digital platforms amplify and standardize these rejection criteria. Memes, viral videos, and online discussions create a shared language around dating turn-offs, encouraging users to add new, hyper-specific items to their personal lists. This has led to what some call a culture of “checklist dating,” where genuine connection can be secondary to passing a virtual test.

The Rise of Checklist Dating

Young singles are increasingly navigating the dating world with a new tool: the “ick list.”

This phenomenon, driven by viral social media trends, involves creating detailed checklists of behaviors and traits that can cause immediate romantic rejection. From fashion choices to conversational habits, potential partners are being evaluated against criteria shaped by online culture.

What is an ‘Ick’?

The term “ick,” popularized on platforms like TikTok, describes a trait or action that instantly turns a person off. According to reporting from The Guardian, it’s a gut reaction of disgust that can abruptly end a budding romance.

These icks can be significant, but are often trivial. Lea Veloso shared her list with The Sophian, which included everything from “being an unsuccessful DJ” to “saving oneself for marriage.”

Social Media’s Influence

Digital platforms amplify and standardize these rejection criteria. Memes, viral videos, and online discussions create a shared language around dating turn-offs, encouraging users to add new, hyper-specific items to their personal lists. This has led to what some call a culture of “checklist dating,” where genuine connection can be secondary to passing a virtual test.

The Rise of Checklist Dating

Young singles are increasingly navigating the dating world with a new tool: the “ick list.”

This phenomenon, driven by viral social media trends, involves creating detailed checklists of behaviors and traits that can cause immediate romantic rejection. From fashion choices to conversational habits, potential partners are being evaluated against criteria shaped by online culture.

What is an ‘Ick’?

The term “ick,” popularized on platforms like TikTok, describes a trait or action that instantly turns a person off. According to reporting from The Guardian, it’s a gut reaction of disgust that can abruptly end a budding romance.

These icks can be significant, but are often trivial. Lea Veloso shared her list with The Sophian, which included everything from “being an unsuccessful DJ” to “saving oneself for marriage.”

Social Media’s Influence

Digital platforms amplify and standardize these rejection criteria. Memes, viral videos, and online discussions create a shared language around dating turn-offs, encouraging users to add new, hyper-specific items to their personal lists. This has led to what some call a culture of “checklist dating,” where genuine connection can be secondary to passing a virtual test.

Data Shows Widespread Rejection

The “ick” is not a niche concept. A recent poll highlighted by Student Beans revealed that 65% of actively dating Americans have ended a relationship over an ick. Furthermore, a striking 88% admitted to ghosting someone for a similar reason.

Most Common Icks

The same poll identified the most prevalent turn-offs among singles:

  • Smelling bad (24%)

  • Pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%)

  • Being rude to waitstaff (21%)

  • Obsession with star signs (15%)

Interestingly, some icks are gender-specific. For example, 16% of women cited wearing a “tacky watch” as a turn-off.

Icks vs. Red Flags

Experts note a key distinction between icks and red flags. While red flags often signal deeper issues like dishonesty or disrespect, icks are frequently superficial annoyances. However, the line can blur, as some icks—like being apolitical or lying about one’s height—touch upon core values and deal-breakers.

Data Shows Widespread Rejection

The “ick” is not a niche concept. A recent poll highlighted by Student Beans revealed that 65% of actively dating Americans have ended a relationship over an ick. Furthermore, a striking 88% admitted to ghosting someone for a similar reason.

Most Common Icks

The same poll identified the most prevalent turn-offs among singles:

  • Smelling bad (24%)

  • Pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%)

  • Being rude to waitstaff (21%)

  • Obsession with star signs (15%)

Interestingly, some icks are gender-specific. For example, 16% of women cited wearing a “tacky watch” as a turn-off.

Icks vs. Red Flags

Experts note a key distinction between icks and red flags. While red flags often signal deeper issues like dishonesty or disrespect, icks are frequently superficial annoyances. However, the line can blur, as some icks—like being apolitical or lying about one’s height—touch upon core values and deal-breakers.

Data Shows Widespread Rejection

The “ick” is not a niche concept. A recent poll highlighted by Student Beans revealed that 65% of actively dating Americans have ended a relationship over an ick. Furthermore, a striking 88% admitted to ghosting someone for a similar reason.

Most Common Icks

The same poll identified the most prevalent turn-offs among singles:

  • Smelling bad (24%)

  • Pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%)

  • Being rude to waitstaff (21%)

  • Obsession with star signs (15%)

Interestingly, some icks are gender-specific. For example, 16% of women cited wearing a “tacky watch” as a turn-off.

Icks vs. Red Flags

Experts note a key distinction between icks and red flags. While red flags often signal deeper issues like dishonesty or disrespect, icks are frequently superficial annoyances. However, the line can blur, as some icks—like being apolitical or lying about one’s height—touch upon core values and deal-breakers.

A Shift in 2025 Dating

As quickly as the “ick” became a dating staple, a counter-movement is emerging.

Dating platforms and trend reports for 2025, including analysis from The Everygirl, indicate a growing desire for more authentic and forgiving approaches to romance.

From Ick to ‘StICKing’

The leading counter-trend is “StICKing.” This concept encourages singles to look past minor, superficial icks and give potential partners a genuine chance. The goal is to prioritize real connection over an impossible standard of perfection.

Other Emerging Trends

Alongside StICKing, other trends are pushing back against checklist culture:

  • Niche Interests: Daters are actively seeking partners who share micro-interests and fandoms, valuing specific shared passions over generic compatibility.

  • Micro-mance: Grand, dramatic gestures are being replaced by small, personalized acts of intimacy that reflect everyday care and connection.

These shifts suggest that while digital trends can shape dating rules, many are now seeking a return to basics: finding a genuine spark, even if the person doesn’t check every box.

A Shift in 2025 Dating

As quickly as the “ick” became a dating staple, a counter-movement is emerging.

Dating platforms and trend reports for 2025, including analysis from The Everygirl, indicate a growing desire for more authentic and forgiving approaches to romance.

From Ick to ‘StICKing’

The leading counter-trend is “StICKing.” This concept encourages singles to look past minor, superficial icks and give potential partners a genuine chance. The goal is to prioritize real connection over an impossible standard of perfection.

Other Emerging Trends

Alongside StICKing, other trends are pushing back against checklist culture:

  • Niche Interests: Daters are actively seeking partners who share micro-interests and fandoms, valuing specific shared passions over generic compatibility.

  • Micro-mance: Grand, dramatic gestures are being replaced by small, personalized acts of intimacy that reflect everyday care and connection.

These shifts suggest that while digital trends can shape dating rules, many are now seeking a return to basics: finding a genuine spark, even if the person doesn’t check every box.

A Shift in 2025 Dating

As quickly as the “ick” became a dating staple, a counter-movement is emerging.

Dating platforms and trend reports for 2025, including analysis from The Everygirl, indicate a growing desire for more authentic and forgiving approaches to romance.

From Ick to ‘StICKing’

The leading counter-trend is “StICKing.” This concept encourages singles to look past minor, superficial icks and give potential partners a genuine chance. The goal is to prioritize real connection over an impossible standard of perfection.

Other Emerging Trends

Alongside StICKing, other trends are pushing back against checklist culture:

  • Niche Interests: Daters are actively seeking partners who share micro-interests and fandoms, valuing specific shared passions over generic compatibility.

  • Micro-mance: Grand, dramatic gestures are being replaced by small, personalized acts of intimacy that reflect everyday care and connection.

These shifts suggest that while digital trends can shape dating rules, many are now seeking a return to basics: finding a genuine spark, even if the person doesn’t check every box.

What are some common icks people have today?

According to a recent poll from <a href="https://www.studentbeans.com" target="_blank">Student Beans</a>, some of the most common icks include bad smells (reported by 24% of singles), pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%), being rude to waitstaff (21%), wearing a tacky watch (16% of women), and having an obsession with star signs (15%).

What are some common icks people have today?

According to a recent poll from <a href="https://www.studentbeans.com" target="_blank">Student Beans</a>, some of the most common icks include bad smells (reported by 24% of singles), pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%), being rude to waitstaff (21%), wearing a tacky watch (16% of women), and having an obsession with star signs (15%).

What are some common icks people have today?

According to a recent poll from <a href="https://www.studentbeans.com" target="_blank">Student Beans</a>, some of the most common icks include bad smells (reported by 24% of singles), pretending to be a “know-it-all” (21%), being rude to waitstaff (21%), wearing a tacky watch (16% of women), and having an obsession with star signs (15%).

How do dating trends differ between generations?

How do dating trends differ between generations?

How do dating trends differ between generations?

What are the benefits of embracing romance in a new way?

What are the benefits of embracing romance in a new way?

What are the benefits of embracing romance in a new way?

How does the concept of "StICKing" impact modern dating?

How does the concept of "StICKing" impact modern dating?

How does the concept of "StICKing" impact modern dating?

What are some of the most trivial 'icks' people have reported?

What are some of the most trivial 'icks' people have reported?

What are some of the most trivial 'icks' people have reported?